What is Truth?

You can’t handle the _____________.

The whole _________ and nothing but the ______________.

_________ or dare.

_________ hurts.

We hold these ___________ (truths) to be self evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

Great words, but are they true. Put another way, does the fact that Thomas Jefferson who wrote those words and many of the men who signed the Declaration of Independence owned and traded in men, women, and children, made money and wealth from slavery, does the fact that they believed that only white men who were educated and wealthy enough to own land were truly equal, and the fact that women didn’t even enter the picture, do those facts make those words less true?

You see there is a difference between facts and truth. As poet, author, and speaker Maya Angelou has said, “There’s a world of difference between truth and facts. Facts can obscure the truth.” I think Pontius Pilate would agree. I also think knowlege, that awareness is behind his now timeless question, “what is truth?”.

You see he knew the facts. He wasn’t a dummy. He knew it was Passover. A tense time for the people. A time when they celebrated God rescuing and redeeming them from another, a different, overlord and empire. He knew the people didn’t come to this festival just to remember something God did once in the past, but to pray and look forward to God acting today. He knew that some people would agitate and perhaps do even more to free the people of God from Roman rule and oppression. And, Pilate knew the religious leaders had it in for Jesus, that they wanted to get rid of him. He also knew that Jesus was innocent. Pilate could see the facts; he was looking for the truth.

I think a lot of us are more like Pilate than we would first admit. I know I am. We know the facts. The facts are people get sick, children get cancer, some parents hurt their children. The facts are we are burning and using up our planet and our resources. The facts are the wealthiest in our country are getting richer and the rest of us aren’t, in fact many are poorer. The fact is our economic and educational systems do not encourage justice and equality. The facts are that our policies and laws often target poor people and people of color. The facts are sometimes planes crash, and countries fight wars with others or with themselves. The facts are that while there is only one race, the human race, we use our ethnic and cultural differences as reasons for mean-spiritedness, hatred, and even violence. The facts are sometimes marriages and relationships end. The facts are people lie to one another.

Those are the facts. What is truth? What is the truth that helps us make sense in a senseless world. What is the truth that goes beyond all these facts of life?

In John’s gospel Jesus has a lot to say about truth. Jesus uses the word truth 21 times in John’s gospel. If you add up all the times he says the word truth in the other three gospels, Matthew, Mark, and Luke it totals 6. In John’s gospel truth is a big deal.

I think it’s a pretty big deal in life too. The slide show over here has just a few of Jesus’s words about truth. I think a central word, is Jesus’ statement–I am the way, the truth, and the life. So if Jesus is the truth, what does that mean? What do we believe about Jesus?

Who is Jesus to you?

We have a lot of things to say about Jesus. It all boils down to being connected to him, being grounded, tied and bound to him. Jesus is our truth. His life, his words, his work that is not facts–but our truth.

And that truth will set us free, but that truth in our story for today was bound, bound by ropes, perhaps even chains. That is fact, that jesus was arrested and bound. But The Truth is that it was not chains and weapons, betrayers and soldiers that made him stand before Pilate. It was love. Jesus was not bound by violence and force, but by love. His love for us. Jesus ties himself to us, to all of us.

One of the good things about being a city church is not having a church cemetery–like some country churches. It saves us a lot of headache and hard work. Well at some time I came across a story of a small country church, their cemetery had a fieldstone wall around it. Well as it happened one day a not so beloved member of the community died. He was a mean and bitter man. He had served time for some crime that well, there were lots of rumors about. Anyway, he died and a member of his family asked for him to be buried in the church cemetery. The cemetery committee met and voted to deny the request. They would not allow him to be buried on their sacred ground, but just outside the cemetery wall. So the pastor, just a couple of people from his family held his funeral. It was a Saturday, as many funerals go. The next morning as members of the church drove past the cemetery, they were shocked to see that the fieldstone wall had been moved. It now went around the newly filled grave .

Whatever the facts are, whether it was moved overnight by some hard working individuals or by a miracle. Either way, the facts don’t matter. The truth does. And the truth is. Jesus is friend, teacher, brother, healer, savior. Facts do not guide us each day. Facts do not give us comfort in grief. Facts do not give us hope in pain. Jesus is claiming us. We belong to the truth, to him. Jesus is our truth. It is through him that we see, judge, understand, and give meaning to the facts of this life. The truth is that God is love, Jesus is from God, we belong with Jesus, Jesus is truth, the truth that we belong to, the truth that binds us together is love. That is our truth. Amen.

Truth hurts, love frees – Sermon for Sun. Nov. 10th, 2013, Narrative Lectionary, passages from the prophet Amos

It’s a real special kinda person who likes to criticize, castigate, and slam other people.   It takes another kind of person who can really take it, I mean listen well to criticism and judgement. As the Ancient Greek playwrite, Sophocles declared,” No one loves the messenger who brings bad news.”  Giving and receiving criticism, well it’s just not pleasant.  I guess that’s why we say, the truth hurts.  It hurts so much that we have developed a whole system of little white lies to be polite.  “My your shirt is–colorful; that dish was tasty, I’ve never tasted anything like it”.  We are trying to be nice, to say nice things even if we don’t think them, so that we don’t offend or hurt feelings.


We don’t get any of that from the prophet Amos.  In fact, that whole being nice thing it’s not really very biblical.  Nowhere are we extolled to be nice.  We are definitely supposed to love, there’s no exemptions or exceptions to that.  But love, love isn’t always nice, and it, like truth, can hurt.  The church leader and gospel spreader, Paul writes to a church in Ephesus, that we are to   “speak the truth in love”. Ephesians 4.15.


I think that’s how we need to also hear the words of the prophet Amos.  Because, well Amos doesn’t have nice things to say about or to the people of God in his day.  But let us not forget,  these are not just Amos’ words, he’s not grinding his own axe.  His only agenda is to speak the word of The Lord.  And although these are hard words, they are spoken from a place of love.


God called Amos to leave his own country, the south and preach in the northern kingdom of Israel. Now this isn’t the first time a prophet has words of condemnation.  A couple weeks ago, we heard about Elijah who contended with the King and queen who were worshipping some god named Baal, and just to be clear it wasn’t footbaal–BAAL


With the prophet Amos, the problem wasn’t to whom the people were praying.  They were praying with their lips; they were offering sacrifices, they were singing songs of praise and thanksgiving to The Lord God.   It’s hard enough to knock (tear) down a bunch of altars, high places, and temples to some other god, but today’s word from The Lord we heard from Amos, is even harder.  The problem was with something much more difficult to deal with.  It was with their way of life, their economic system.  And no one wants to hear that they way we are living, the way we are going about our business is all wrong. The people of God didn’t need to worship the idols and gods of the neighbors to become just like them. 


The had developed an economy, a way of running things that was set up so that some people would get really, really rich, as Amos says live in big houses made of stone, get fat from fancy food and lots of wine.  And all these profits, these good things were made at the expense of the rest of the people.  Some had lots, but lots had very little.  Sound familiar?  Well, the hard truth is we are not much better.  Now I know this may be a hard word to hear.  No one, no exceptions, including me wants to be told that they way we are doing things isn’t right.


It should make us uncomfortable to know that we live, work, and most importantly worship God in one of the most segregated cities in the country, where almost a third of the city’s residents and just over 40% of our children, live in poverty. We live in a country that cuts food aid to almost one million veterans, people working jobs that do not pay enough to support families, to elderly and children.   We live in a sick system.  All sorts of tax breaks and incentives and subsidies go to wealthy and to corporations, but we insist we need to balance a budget, it’s being balanced on the backs of the poorest and most vulnerable. 


Today, just as in Amos’ day,  this is not God’s will, not God’s intention.  We continue to create our idols and bow to them, today we call them capitalism, we call them success, we call them, “that’s just the way it is”.  Even charity has become an idol.  For some say that all we are to do is give a little bit to the poor,you know a hand out now and then.  No for the prophets of The Lord the problem is deeper. 


We all want our entitlements.  We want cheap gas and other energy, cheap clothing even if the workers are paid pennies a day and live and sometimes die in sweatshops, we want our social security checks that will go far beyond what we have paid into the system.  Remember though as God’s people we don’t just speak the truth, do not hear me pointing fingers at you, we’re all part of the problem–with our purchases, votes, with our silence, and just minding our own business, taking care of our own.


Through the prophet Amos and believing that ours is a God of love, we can hear these words.  Otherwise, it would be so easy to just dismiss us, give up on us, leave us to our own sinful devices.  As I’m sure you’ve heard, and I didn’t come up with.  God loves us just the way we are, but God loves us too much to let us stay that way.  There’s a practice among community organizers, it’s called agitation.  The thing is they don’t agitate everybody, they agitate themselves and each other.  They are pushing one another to grow, to become better, to act stronger and with more purpose.


That’s what God was doing when a bunch of slaves were rescued from slavery in Egypt.  That’s what’s behind all the laws that God gave them in the wilderness.  It wasn’t just a way to get to a promised land, God’s promise was a land where they could live God’s way.  Where sabbath rest meant that slaves and foreigners and even the land were not abused and used up by our greedy desires.  Where widows, orphans, elderly were not abandoned, where everybody gave a hand to pull someone up by the proverbial bootstrap.  Where debts were forgiven.


With this truth, with the words of Amos, and with preachers and prophets, God’s truth is trying to set us free.  Remember truth in love.  We are not slaves to a sinful system that says our value is only tied to how much money we have, where we live, what the color of our skin is, what language we speak.  We are set free to struggle to break open oppressions so that justice can flow freely for everyone, and not just those who can afford it.  With every purchase, every decision, every vote, every letter or email to a government official.  God is giving us a vision of justice to guide all our choices.  So, if the cuts to SNAP, and the debate over the farm bill are important, our church can help you speak up and speak out, to do your Christian duty to contact your legislator, and put your faith into action.  Out in the lobby, I have some handouts for the ELCA office for Advocacy and public policy.  We are called to show-up and be part of the decisions that impact people’s lives–issues like immigration reform, civil rights for all people, and more.  Our faith calls us to show up when and where decisions are being made. 


Just as we can readily admit none of us is perfect, and we try to live, act, believe, think better.  We are freed by Amos and the prophets, most importantly freed by Jesus to admit, to confess, to be convicted that the political, the economic, the cultural systems of our world are not perfect (oftentimes not even close), and that we can, that God expects us to do something about it.  If you can, this week read the whole book Amos. I will admit it is hard, do not get too depressed, do not quit, read it all the way through, even that last chapter.  For those words are promises, God’s promise that the days are coming, and in Christ they are here, and now a time to rebuild, restore, repair, and replenish.  God is raising us up to the freedom of God’s true promised land, a place for all– no exclusion, no exceptions, no exemptions.  Amen